“Guys, where are we?” said Charlie in the premiere of Lost, way back when. He could have said the same thing when he landed in LAX in season six.
The genius of the series finale is its satisfaction while maintaining mystery. Rather than tying up loose ends and having everything explained and fit together, the writers did something different. They closed it off with the finality of death but with a hopefulness and comfort that only an afterlife brings.
Bloggers and Lost fans will no doubt debate what the series meant, or what the parallel time lines were, but I think it’s clear. The people of Lost were broken and in need of different things: purpose, love, challenges. When they crashed onto the island they fought for their lives, and in doing so came together and mended. They found forgiveness and purpose and for many, healing.
The plane never landed in LAX. There was no parallel time line. Early theories about the show were that the island was some kind of ethereal place. Some said it was Hell, others said it was Purgatory or some kind of Limbo. But the island was always real, it was the parallel life that wasn’t. It was where characters went to meet up with each other before crossing over into Heaven.
Kate, Sawyer, Miles, and Claire all lived on, escaping the island and doing who knows what with their lives. When Kate meets up with Jack again in the place between worlds, she tells him she’s waited so long to see him again. Hugo tells Ben he was a good number two, and Ben replies in thanks and that Hugo was a good number one. Both lived on the island, for many years it seems, protecting the light. Ben was not ready to move on, he still had to work things out, which is an idea pretty consistent with Purgatory or Limbo: you don’t move on until your ready. Ben still had to forgive himself.
I found it fitting that “Christian Shephard” gathered the people and lead them on. That they all gathered in a church (the same church where Eloise told them they had to go back to the island, I think) to meet up again, embrace, and move on, was poetic.
Did Lost tie up all the loose ends or explain all the mysteries? No. It didn’t need to. There will be people who demand to know about the significance of Walt or Aaron, but neither is relevant. The island was a mystery, it contained something that people didn’t understand. It makes sense then that the show would still have mysteries of its own.
Charles Widmore, despite being rich and powerful, was just a simple cog in the machine. His purpose, after all his meddling, was simply to bring Desmond back to the Island. Without Desmond, the smoke monster could have never been destroyed and would have been a constant threat. But thanks to Charles, the smoke monster was destroyed.
Lost was about life, and ultimately death. The characters were lost until they all found each other, after fulfilling some kind of purpose, finding meaning and love, reconciling, becoming whole. And then they moved on together.